The Climate Docket

WHAT WE COVER:

  • Liability Litigation
    • Baltimore Lawsuit
    • California Climate Lawsuits
    • Colorado Lawsuit
    • Mass. v. Exxon
    • New York City Lawsuit
    • Rhode Island Lawsuit
    • Other Suits
  • Access to Courts
    • Liability Waivers
    • State Legislation
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe

Powered by Genesis

You are here: Home / Featured / Necessity Defense Goes Untested in Climate Activists’ Acquittal
Necessity Defense Goes Untested in Climate Activists’ Acquittal

Necessity Defense Goes Untested in Climate Activists’ Acquittal

October 9, 2018 Filed Under: Featured

print
By Seamus McGraw

It ended almost as soon as it began.

In a stunning ruling that came just minutes after the jury was seated in the so-called valve turners trial in Clearfield County, Minn., the judge ruled that prosecutors had failed to meet their burden of proof that a group of activists had damaged a tar sands pipeline when they trespassed on private property to shut down the pipeline.

The judge dismissed all charges against the defendants: Emily Johnston and Annette Klapstein, who were facing up to 10 years on felony counts related to the incident, and Benjamin Joldersma, who faced misdemeanor charges for assisting them.

The ruling effectively short-circuited what many activists and legal scholars hoped would be a landmark trial and the first real test of the necessity defense. The defendants had planned to present evidence they trespassed to shut down an Enbridge pipeline carrying tar sands oil from Alberta because the pipeline represents a direct and immediate climate threat and their actions were their best option to confront the peril.

The activists and their lawyers wanted to win acquittal, but they also wanted to put climate change on trial in an American courtroom.

Earlier this year, an appeals court in Minnesota ruled that they could proceed with the necessity defense.

But just three days before the trial was slated to begin, Judge Robert Tiffany ruled that only five of the nine expert witnesses the defendants planned to call would be permitted to testify. That roster still included some heavy hitters, including former NASA scientist James Hansen, public health expert Bruce Snyder, former Cornell University professor and pipeline expert Anthony Ingraffea.

As late as Monday night, defense attorney Lauren Regan of the Eugene, Ore., based Civil Liberties Defense Center, remained confident that the witnesses and direct testimony from the defendants would sway a jury, even one in this archly conservative region of an otherwise purple state.

But they never got a chance.

Regan expressed mixed feelings about the result at a hastily arranged press conference on the courthouse steps. “We are obviously now relieved that the criminal charges have been dismissed,” Regan said, “but there’s a lot of work to do regarding climate change and the underlying issues.

“Of course we are ecstatic that we were acquitted,” Klapstein said. “That was awesome. But because we were unable to present our story to the jurors, we do want people to know that we took every precaution we could to make sure that the people of Clearwater County were safe. I spent 30 years practicing law, trying to protect people from all kinds of harms and I would never do anything to put people in harm’s way.”

The Clearwater County Attorney said through a spokeswoman that there are no plans to refile charges in the case.

That came as no surprise to Ingraffea, who had arrived after a multi-layover trip, but never got a chance to testify. “It’s a strategic loss on the part of the prosecution,” Ingraffea said. “They were willing to let the defendants go so that they didn’t have to endure the publicity around the necessity defense.”

 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Featured

Don't Miss a story
Subscribe 
We promise not to spam you. Unsubscribe at any time.
Invalid email address
Thanks for subscribing! Please check your email for further instructions.

Trackbacks

  1. The SIX dumbest and most absurd stories of 2018 – iftttwall says:
    January 4, 2019 at 11:50 am

    […] October, charges were suddenly dropped against the activists. This actually upset some activists who hoped that the case would set a […]

  2. Are These The Six Most Absurd Stories Of 2018? – iftttwall says:
    January 4, 2019 at 3:57 pm

    […] October, charges were suddenly dropped against the activists. This actually upset some activists who hoped that the case would set a […]

  3. Are These The Six Most Absurd Stories Of 2018? | StockTalk Journal says:
    January 4, 2019 at 4:15 pm

    […] October, charges were suddenly dropped against the activists. This actually upset some activists who hoped that the case would set a […]

  4. Are These The Six Most Absurd Stories Of 2018? | Real Patriot News says:
    January 4, 2019 at 4:33 pm

    […] October, charges were suddenly dropped against the activists. This actually upset some activists who hoped that the case would set a […]

  5. Simon Black: The Six DUMBEST And MOST ABSURD Stories Of 2018 – Gold Aim Pro says:
    January 4, 2019 at 7:09 pm

    […] October, charges were suddenly dropped against the activists. This actually upset some activists who hoped that the case would set a […]

  6. The SIX dumbest and most absurd stories of 2018 - The Daily Coin says:
    January 6, 2019 at 6:45 am

    […] October, charges were suddenly dropped against the activists. This actually upset some activists who hoped that the case would set a […]

  7. The SIX dumbest and most absurd stories of 2018 | Exceptional Insights says:
    February 14, 2019 at 12:24 am

    […] October, charges were suddenly dropped against the activists. This actually upset some activists who hoped that the case would set a […]

  8. Climate activists win necessity defense trial in London says:
    May 10, 2019 at 7:42 am

    […] could use the necessity defense to justify their shutting down of a tar sand pipeline. The trial ended in an acquittal of the protesters, Annette Klapstein, Emily Johnson, Steve Liptay and Benjamin Joldersma, but in […]

Don't Miss a story
Subscribe 
We promise not to spam you. Unsubscribe at any time.
Invalid email address
Thanks for subscribing! Please check your email for further instructions.

Latest News

Justice Dept. to Argue on Side of Oil Companies in Supreme Court Hearing

By Karen Savage The acting solicitor general will be allowed time to argue in support of ExxonMobil, Chevron, Shell, BP and nearly two dozen other companies next week during oral arguments before … [Read More...]

Recent Posts

  • Colorado Judge Rejects Oil Companies’ Attempt to Move Climate Case
  • Biden’s DOJ Could Help Swing Momentum Around Climate Cases
  • Supreme Court Questions Oil Companies’ Tactics to Shake Climate Cases
  • Will Amy Coney Barrett, Whose Father Was a Shell Attorney for Decades, Recuse from Climate Suit?

Most Popular

  • Climate Case Gets Green Light from European Union Court
  • What Oil Companies Knew About Climate Change and When: A Timeline
  • Court: Climate Impacts of Pipeline Projects Cannot Be Ignored
  • Richmond Battles Chevron, Its Biggest Employer, in Two Important Lawsuits
  • France, Home of the Paris Agreement, Faces Lawsuit for Lack of Climate Progress

Categories

  • Access to Courts
  • Baltimore Lawsuit
  • California Climate Lawsuits
  • Charleston, S.C. Lawsuit
  • Colorado Lawsuit
  • Connecticut Lawsuit
  • Delaware Lawsuit
  • Exxon Climate Investigation
  • Featured
  • Hoboken Lawsuit
  • International
  • Latest News
  • Liability Litigation
  • Liability Waivers
  • Mass. v. Exxon
  • Minnesota Lawsuit
  • New York City Lawsuit
  • Other Suits
  • Politics
  • Rhode Island Lawsuit
  • State Legislation
  • Uncategorized
  • Washington DC Lawsuit

Follow us

  • View climatedocket’s profile on Facebook
  • View climatedocket’s profile on Twitter

RSS

RSS Feed RSS - Posts

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.